“the Magnalia does not simply narrate Puritan New England—it stores New England, gathering its poetry, polity, institutional memory, and spiritual self-understanding into a single monumental folio.” Michael Windship
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjahXDqLL0o (Michael P. Winship, “Hot Protestants: A History of Puritanism in England and America” (Yale UP, 2002.) (https://bookshop.org/a/12343/97803001…) (Yale UP, 2019).
908J Cotton Mather
MAGNALIA CHRISTI AMERICANA: OR, THE ECCLESIASTICAL HISTORY OF NEW-ENGLAND, FROM ITS FIRST PLANTING IN THE YEAR 1620. UNTO THE YEAR OF OUR LORD, 1698. IN SEVEN BOOKS.
London: Thomas Parkhurst, 1702. Price $9,000
Folio, 32×20 cm. Signatures A-C4,D2:[Book I] map, A-F4, Aa-Ii4,Kk2, Aaa-Uuu4, Xxx-Zzz4, Aaaa-Gggg4, Aaaa-Mmmm4, Nnnn2, Aaaaa-Mmmmm4,Nnnnn2 Aaaaaa-Llllll4,Mmmmmm2 Aaaaaaa-Ooooooo4,Ppppppp3, +2 ( the first page of advertisements signed A6 the next leaf of advertisements unsigned) Bound in original paneled calf, rebacked in the nineteenth century. With the arms of The writers of the Signet stamped on the boards \. Original map mounted. The contents has been amended in pen with page number (quite helpful)
As Mather biographer Kenneth Silverman explains, the Magnalia Christi Americana , as published in the first London edition of 1702,
“was unmistakably a grandly imagined and formidable work: about eight hundred folio pages of double columns, divided in seven substantial books – history of the settlement of New England; lives of the governors; lives of the leading ministers (the longest book); history of Harvard College, with the lives of eminent graduates; account of the New England manner of worship; ‘Remarkables of Divine Providence’; and a history of the invasion of the New England churches by heretics, Andros, devils, Indians, and others. Mather gathered this information industriously and from many sources: surviving diaries, letters, and other papers; his father’s correspondence; the manuscript histories of New England by William Hubbard and William Bradford; personal acquaintance with surviving members of the earlier generations, the sermon notebooks in which he had taken down their words firsthand, informants who had known them.” Far from being a dull chronicle of events, the Magnalia is full of lively biographical pieces, vivid descriptions of the times, and many surprising sidelights. It has been mined by modern scholars for its unsurpassed view of New England at the end of the 17th century. As Silverman points out, the “enduring importance” of the book “lies in its sheer amassment of precious information about the early history of New England – about leaders in church and state, Puritan relations with the Indians, the development of Harvard, the 1689 revolt, the expeditions against Canada, the Salem trials.”
The Magnalia Christi Americana is also significant as a documentary history of early New England and, unexpectedly, as a small anthology of early American poetry. Mather reproduces or paraphrases more than forty poems, including funeral elegies, Latin verses by early Harvard graduates, metrical paraphrases of Scripture, epitaphs, sermon-prefaces in verse, and occasional poems written for ordinations, fast days, and public events. These verses—some preserved nowhere else—provide a rare cross-section of the literary culture of the late seventeenth century, ranging from simple devotional couplets to sophisticated neo-Latin compositions that reveal the classical training of the early colonial clergy.
At the same time, Mather includes a remarkable suite of foundational documents that function as a primary record of Puritan ecclesiology in New England. These include:
The Cambridge Platform (1648)
The Confession of Faith adopted by the New England churches
Ordination charges, covenant formulas, and church-gathering procedures
The Harvard College laws and key institutional documents
Proclamations, election sermons, and public fast-day declarations
Biographical testimonies and spiritual “relations” from early ministers
Taken together, these embedded texts turn the Magnalia Christi Americana into a portable archive, preserving materials that might otherwise have been lost through the wars, fires, and manuscript attrition of the seventeenth century. As Michael Winship observed, the Magnalia does not simply narrate Puritan New England—it stores New England, gathering its poetry, polity, institutional memory, and spiritual self-understanding into a single monumental folio.
The Map (“The First Eighteenth-Century General Map of New England”) Barbara McCorkle identifies the map in this edition as the first general printed map of New England to appear in the eighteenth century. It covers New England, Long Island, and eastern New York, and derives from Phillip Lea’s circa-1680 New Map of New England, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland & Virginia. Though simplified, it was the most current synoptic printed geography available to London readers in 1702 and the first to circulate widely in conjunction with a historical text.
When we read Cotton Mather today, we’re not just reading Puritan history; we’re watching the earliest printed version of a debate we’re still having which is : who belongs in the story of America. The Magnalia Christi Americana reveals a world far more diverse than the myth allows: Indigenous scholars and translators, African servants, dissenters, women who shaped communities, people moving across languages and cultures. But because Mather writes from inside a narrow frame of power, many of these voices survive only at the margins. That’s why the book matters now. It shows that the fight over identity, inclusion, and memory did not begin in the 20th century—New England was already wrestling with it in 1702. Understanding that struggle helps us approach our own with more humility, more accuracy, and perhaps a little more imagination.
Cotton Mather wasn’t just writing history—he was creating a framework and system for who gets remembered.
By 1702, New England was undergoing dramatic change: the Dominion of New England had collapsed; Harvard was shifting away from strict clerical control; dissenting voices, Baptists, Quakers, Anglicans—were gaining ground; Native communities were destabilized after King Philip’s War.
As Puritan authority was visibly thinning, Mather writes a history that shapes the future by curating the past. He does this by choosing, which ministers exemplify virtue, which Natives represent “civilizing” success, which heresies deserve condemnation. And which institutions-Harvard above all-represent the Puritan achievement. Therefore, this book can be seen as the most significant colonial effort to shape how an entire region remembers its past.
The Magnalia Christi Americana is one of the earliest American texts that consciously negotiates Difference and Diversity. And it is almost always structured by a social/racial/sexual hierarchically. Which voices are elevated? Which are softened? Which are left out? Magnalia Christi Americana is a foundational document of the politics of inclusion/exclusion, a defensive manifesto of Puritan survival.
By 1702 Harvard was drifting toward a broader humanist curriculum, increasing secular governance, and the beginnings of a “post-Puritan New England.” Mather feared the college would lose its identity as a training ground for a learned, disciplined, morally vigilant ministry.
With the Magnalia Christi Americana, Cotton Mather creates a canonization of Harvard’s founders and early graduates. A deliberate claim that New England’s cultural authority rests in the learned clergy.
A way to show London that the colonies possess a “scholarly establishment” aspiring to be equal to Oxford/Cambridge. “Our ministers, bred at the College, have been the pillars and ornaments of the country, men of knowledge and courage, without whom this wilderness had never been a habitation for civility or religion”. Harvard’s early history is a laboratory of limited inclusion made up of elite male clergy, almost entirely English-descended, with Native students enrolled only within missionary frameworks.
Mather deeply respects Eliot’s missionary/ linguistic genius, he understands how extraordinary the Massachusett-language Bible was he writes ““God had furnished him with a singular dexterity of language, that he might be the evangelist of these nations.” Eliot represents the height of Puritan intellectual achievement: mastery of language in service of salvation. “He compassed the whole dialect, framed a grammar of it, and translated the whole Bible into it, a work which no other Englishman durst have attempted.” As the Magnalia Christi Americana celebrates Eliot’s Indian Bible at length, but the Indigenous printers who made it possible—figures like James Printer—are almost entirely absent. The text preserves the miracle of translation, but not the Native intellectual labor that produced it.”
But Mather reframes Native evangelization as a test of Puritan election. The successes confirm providence. Mather states this thus: “The Lord so smiled upon his undertakings, that many of the poor Indians embraced the Gospel, which we took for a token of His favorable presence among us.” The failures confirm divine chastisement. “When the work did not prosper, we judged that God was showing us our own sins and calling New England to repentance.”
When Mather writes “In their dispositions toward the Gospel we saw our own obedience or disobedience reflected, as in a glass.” Native people become moral instruments in Puritan self-definition.
The Magnalia Christi Americana quietly rewrites the trauma of King Philip’s War. “This bloody war was a rod in the hand of God, to scourge a provoking people, that we might be purged from our declensions.” The Magnalia avoids the full devastation of the conflict, instead folding it into a providential narrative about purification and trial.
Native individuality is recognized, but only insofar as it affirms Puritan theology. Mather celebrates people like Daniel Takawambpait, the Native minister at Natick, but not in a way that allows for equal cultural authority. ““Daniel was an Indian of good understanding, well instructed in the doctrines of our holy religion, and able to teach the same unto others. In his ministry he kept close to the sound articles of the faith which he had received from his teachers and swerved not.”
For Mather, Native lives matter but only in the sense that they become evidence in a Puritan moral drama. The Magnalia preserves these voices—but in a constricted way.
When modern audiences hear “DEI,” they think of contemporary institutions.
Because New England’s 17th-century world was full of diversity, negotiation, and contested inclusion: Indigenous nations with sovereign traditions, English colonists from varying religious subcultures Africans (free, enslaved, and indentured) present from the 1630s Dutch, French, Scots, Irish, and Atlantic-world merchants.
As well as Women who ran farms, shops, and households, often acting as de facto clergy in dispersed settlements. Yet the witch is the only female figure in the Magnalia who has causal power, and that power must be demonized. What’s striking in the Magnalia is that women are neither fully absent nor fully present. Outside of witchcraft, they appear almost exclusively as pious supports to male institutions. Witchcraft becomes the one narrative space where women are allowed agency, and that agency must be explained as diabolical. In that sense, women function as an excluded third category in Mather’s construction of New England’s history. As Mather writes “There were women who freely confessed that they had made a covenant with the Devil, and had been his instruments to afflict the bodies of others.” (Magnalia, Book VII p. 312) There was no legitimate covenant available to women that allowed independent, public, authoritative action.
Also there are the Minor sects; Baptists, Quakers, Antinomians. In the Magnalia, Baptists are treated as inconveniences, Antinomians as infections, Quakers as disorderly enthusiasts, and Witches as agents of chaos, each group marking a different boundary of what Puritan New England could tolerate.
There also existed perhapse more Linguistic multiplicity than now: Massachusett, Wampanoag, Mohegan-Pequot, English, Dutch, French
Yet the institutions of Church, Harvard, and Magistracy; were controlled by a remarkably narrow demographic.
**“The Magnalia shows us that DEI didn’t appear out of nowhere. It reveals the oldest American struggle: who gets to belong, who gets to speak, and whose story defines the community?”**
The Magnalia reminds us that America’s story was never simple. Seventeenth-century New England was already negotiating diversity and inclusion—Native scholars, African laborers, women, dissenters—yet only some voices became ‘official’ history. Mather shaped memory through this book and still shapes it today.
Holmes, Cotton Mather 213A .; Howes M391, “.”; Streeter 658.; Grolier AMERICAN 100, 6.; EUROPEAN AMERICANA 702/127.;Sabin 46392.; Church 806.; Larnde 3054.; Bradford 3370.; McCorkleE 702.3, 680.4 (ref).; Cummins, British maps of America, pp.31-33.; Map Forum, Printed maps of New England, 1702:01.; Kenneth Silverman, The Life and Times of Cotton Mather (New York: Harper & Row, 1970), p.158. Jonathan L. Fairbanks and Robert F. Trent, eds., New England Begins: The Seventeenth Century, Vol. 2 (Boston: Museum of Fine Arts, 1982), p.152. Michael Kraus, The Writing of American History (Norman: Univ. of Oklahoma Press, 1953), p.36. McCORKLE, New England in Early Printed Maps, 1513 to 1800: An Illustrated Carto-Bibliography (Providence, RI, The John Carter Brown Library, 2001),
For university and special collections purchases, I am accustomed to working within committee timelines and budget cycles. Titles may be placed on hold during review, and flexible invoicing arrangements can be discussed where appropriate. I welcome inquiries at jamesgray2@me.com.
I am always happy to arrange a brief Zoom or FaceTime appointment to view this or any other of my books.
JAMES GRAY BOOKSELLER
Catalogue CC3 Printed books 1470-1501 New
Century Catalogue Nº 2\ 1501-1599 New
17th Century books MMXXVI New
Annotated 15th &16th C Books New
Twenty Books by, for, or about Women New
jamesgray2@me.com
Jamesgray2@me.com
Leave a Reply